safemode.space
← All techniques
EX-0012
ST0004Execution

Modify On-Board Values

Description

The attacker alters live or persistent data that the spacecraft uses to make decisions and route work. Targets include device and control registers, parameter and limit tables, internal routing/subscriber maps, schedules and timelines, priority/QoS settings, watchdog and timer values, autonomy/FDIR rule tables, ephemeris and attitude references, and power/thermal setpoints. Many missions expose legitimate mechanisms for updating these artifacts, direct memory read/write commands, table load services, file transfers, or maintenance procedures, which can be invoked to steer behavior without changing code. Edits may be transient (until reset) or latched/persistent across boots; they can be narrowly scoped (a single bit flip on an enable mask) or systemic (rewriting a routing table so commands are misdelivered). The effect space spans subtle biasing of control loops, selective blackholing of commands or telemetry, rescheduling of operations, and wholesale changes to mode logic, all accomplished by modifying the values the software already trusts and consumes.

Mappings

EU regulation articles

  • craAnnex I, Part I, (2)(d)
    addresses
    high
    derived

    Authentication and access-management obligations bound which actors can write to live or persistent on-board values.

  • craAnnex I, Part I, (2)(f)
    addresses
    high
    derived

    Integrity protection on stored, transmitted and processed data, commands, programs and configurations is the manufacturer-side obligation directly engaged by on-board-value modification.

  • craAnnex I, Part I, (2)(l)
    addresses
    moderate
    derived

    Logging/monitoring obligation captures parameter modifications and on-board-value changes as evidentiary trail.

  • eu-space-actArt. 81(3)
    addresses
    high
    direct

    Direct memory commands, table loaders, and maintenance procedures that edit on-board values must be governed by 81(3)(b)'s restrict-access-to-critical-functions clause — the population that can invoke these mechanisms must be bounded.

  • eu-space-actArt. 84(2)
    addresses
    high
    direct

    Modifying live or persistent on-board values attacks the integrity of network and information systems; 84(2)'s Annex VII point 5.1 compliance includes integrity protection on the data structures EX-0012 targets.

  • nis2Art. 21(2)(b)
    addresses
    moderate
    derived

    Silent value modification (mode-logic edits, FDIR-rule rewrites, ephemeris drift) is detectable via configuration-integrity baselines; Art. 21(2)(b)'s incident-handling capability must surface those signals despite the absence of obvious protocol anomalies.

  • nis2Art. 21(2)(h)
    addresses
    moderate
    inferred

    Signed table loads and authenticated parameter edits are cryptographic mechanisms that defeat malicious data introduced via legitimate load and write mechanisms, but they do not cover direct configuration and data tampering by an adversary with write access, where the operative control is system-integrity and access control. The CIR (EU) 2024/2690 Annex assigns those to section 6 (6.3 configuration management; 6.9 protection against unauthorised software), not to the section 9 cryptography requirements. At NIS2 Art. 21(2)(h) the relationship is addresses.

  • nis2Art. 21(2)(i)
    addresses
    high
    direct

    Direct memory read/write commands, table-load services, file transfers, and maintenance procedures are access-controlled functions; Art. 21(2)(i)'s access-control + asset-management obligation governs which roles can invoke them and how their use is audited.

  • nis2-implAnnex 11.3.1
    addresses
    high
    derived

    Operators authorized to alter on-board values are privileged-account holders; the privileged-account policy bounds the population that can issue parameter modifications and applies strong identification and review obligations.

  • nis2-implAnnex 3.2.1
    addresses
    high
    derived

    Monitoring-and-logging must surface parameter changes and anomalous on-board-value modifications; this is the detective control for unauthorized modification.

  • nis2-implAnnex 6.4.1
    addresses
    high
    derived

    Modifications to live or persistent on-board values (registers, parameter tables, routing maps) are change-management events; the implementing regulation requires the entity to control changes to network-and-information-system parameters under documented procedures.

ENISA controls

  • ENISA-STL-2025-03-sD.21-i01
    addresses
    high

    Configuration management with documented, monitored, and reviewed configurations is the discipline that detects unauthorised modifications to control data EX-0012 makes.

  • ENISA-STL-2025-03-sD.24-i08
    mitigates
    moderate

    Process-ID whitelisting for bus and payload firmware commanding restricts which IDs can issue the memory-write/load and table-edit commands EX-0012 abuses.

  • ENISA-STL-2025-03-sD.25-i10
    addresses
    moderate

    Integrity checking on mission software and firmware extends to the live and persistent data structures EX-0012 modifies (registers, tables, schedules, autonomy rules).

Cross-reference controls

  • csf-2-0DE.CM-01Networks and network services are monitored to find potentially adverse events
    addresses
    moderate

    Supported by two independent derivations that agree, neither of them SafeMode's invention. Through NIST 800-53: SafeMode's curated mapping records EX-0012 against CM-3 Configuration Change Control, and CSF 2.0's own crosswalk names that control as an informative reference for DE.CM-01. Through SPARTA: SPARTA's catalog maps EX-0012 to countermeasure CM0032 On-board Intrusion Detection & Prevention, and that countermeasure's own CSF references include DE.CM-01. Recorded as `addresses` rather than `mitigates` because a CSF subcategory states an outcome to be achieved while the underlying control states the mechanism that achieves it, which is the mechanism-versus-mandate ceiling in decisions entry 15.

  • csf-2-0DE.CM-09Computing hardware and software, runtime environments, and their data are monitored to find potentially adverse events
    addresses
    moderate

    Supported by two independent derivations that agree, neither of them SafeMode's invention. Through NIST 800-53: SafeMode's curated mapping records EX-0012 against CM-3 Configuration Change Control, and CSF 2.0's own crosswalk names that control as an informative reference for DE.CM-09. Through SPARTA: SPARTA's catalog maps EX-0012 to countermeasure CM0032 On-board Intrusion Detection & Prevention; CM0042 Robust Fault Management; CM0049 Machine Learning Data Integrity, and that countermeasure's own CSF references include DE.CM-09. Recorded as `addresses` rather than `mitigates` because a CSF subcategory states an outcome to be achieved while the underlying control states the mechanism that achieves it, which is the mechanism-versus-mandate ceiling in decisions entry 15. DE.CM-09 is one of CSF's broader outcomes, so this edge locates the technique within CSF's structure rather than naming a specific defence.

  • csf-2-0PR.AA-05Access permissions, entitlements, and authorizations are defined in a policy, managed, enforced, and reviewed, and incorporate the principles of least privilege and separation of duties
    addresses
    moderate

    Supported by two independent derivations that agree, neither of them SafeMode's invention. Through NIST 800-53: SafeMode's curated mapping records EX-0012 against AC-3 Access Enforcement, and CSF 2.0's own crosswalk names that control as an informative reference for PR.AA-05. Through SPARTA: SPARTA's catalog maps EX-0012 to countermeasure CM0038 Segmentation; CM0039 Least Privilege, and that countermeasure's own CSF references include PR.AA-05. Recorded as `addresses` rather than `mitigates` because a CSF subcategory states an outcome to be achieved while the underlying control states the mechanism that achieves it, which is the mechanism-versus-mandate ceiling in decisions entry 15. PR.AA-05 is one of CSF's broader outcomes, so this edge locates the technique within CSF's structure rather than naming a specific defence.

  • csf-2-0PR.DS-10The confidentiality, integrity, and availability of data-in-use are protected
    addresses
    moderate

    Supported by two independent derivations that agree, neither of them SafeMode's invention. Through NIST 800-53: SafeMode's curated mapping records EX-0012 against AC-3 Access Enforcement, and CSF 2.0's own crosswalk names that control as an informative reference for PR.DS-10. Through SPARTA: SPARTA's catalog maps EX-0012 to countermeasure CM0039 Least Privilege, and that countermeasure's own CSF references include PR.DS-10. Recorded as `addresses` rather than `mitigates` because a CSF subcategory states an outcome to be achieved while the underlying control states the mechanism that achieves it, which is the mechanism-versus-mandate ceiling in decisions entry 15. PR.DS-10 is one of CSF's broader outcomes, so this edge locates the technique within CSF's structure rather than naming a specific defence.

  • csf-2-0PR.IR-01Networks and environments are protected from unauthorized logical access and usage
    addresses
    moderate

    Supported by two independent derivations that agree, neither of them SafeMode's invention. Through NIST 800-53: SafeMode's curated mapping records EX-0012 against AC-3 Access Enforcement, and CSF 2.0's own crosswalk names that control as an informative reference for PR.IR-01. Through SPARTA: SPARTA's catalog maps EX-0012 to countermeasure CM0038 Segmentation, and that countermeasure's own CSF references include PR.IR-01. Recorded as `addresses` rather than `mitigates` because a CSF subcategory states an outcome to be achieved while the underlying control states the mechanism that achieves it, which is the mechanism-versus-mandate ceiling in decisions entry 15. PR.IR-01 is one of CSF's broader outcomes, so this edge locates the technique within CSF's structure rather than naming a specific defence.

  • csf-2-0PR.PS-01Configuration management practices are established and applied
    addresses
    moderate

    Supported by two independent derivations that agree, neither of them SafeMode's invention. Through NIST 800-53: SafeMode's curated mapping records EX-0012 against CM-3 Configuration Change Control; CM-5 Access Restrictions for Change, and CSF 2.0's own crosswalk names that control as an informative reference for PR.PS-01. Through SPARTA: SPARTA's catalog maps EX-0012 to countermeasure CM0039 Least Privilege; CM0069 Process White Listing, and that countermeasure's own CSF references include PR.PS-01. Recorded as `addresses` rather than `mitigates` because a CSF subcategory states an outcome to be achieved while the underlying control states the mechanism that achieves it, which is the mechanism-versus-mandate ceiling in decisions entry 15. PR.PS-01 is one of CSF's broader outcomes, so this edge locates the technique within CSF's structure rather than naming a specific defence.

  • mitre-attack-enterpriseT1565Data Manipulation
    addresses
    moderate

    T1565 'Data Manipulation' is the parent-level ATT&CK technique for adversary alteration of stored/transmitted/runtime data to influence outcomes; SPARTA EX-0012 'Modify On-Board Values' is the parent-level spacecraft equivalent (registers, routing tables, parameters, payload data). Cross-tactic moderate (impact vs execution).

  • mitre-attack-icsT0836Modify Parameter
    addresses
    moderate

    T0836 'Modify Parameter' is the ATT&CK ICS technique for adversary modification of control system parameters to manipulate process behavior; SPARTA EX-0012 'Modify On-Board Values' is the parent-level spacecraft equivalent (registers, routing tables, parameters, payload data). Cross-tactic moderate (T0836 in impair-process-control vs SPARTA EX-0012 execution); exact concept match.

  • nasa-bpgMI-DCO-01Mission Adversarial Actions Detection Function
    addresses
    moderate

    Modification of on-board values is the class of action an on-board detector should surface. The practice governs the technique broadly; the parent spans thirteen distinct value classes and the excerpt commits to none of them.

  • nist-80053-rev5AC-2Account Management
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data, nist-ir-8401, nist-ir-8323r1, nist-ir-8441, nist-ir-8270, aerospace-tor-2023-02161

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5AC-3Access Enforcement
    mitigates
    moderate

    AC-3 mitigates EX-0012 by enforcing access authorization on registers, parameter tables, and routing maps.

  • nist-80053-rev5AC-3(11)Restrict Access to Specific Information Types
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5AC-3(13)Attribute-based Access Control
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5AC-3(15)Discretionary and Mandatory Access Control
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5AC-4Information Flow Enforcement
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data, nist-ir-8401, nist-ir-8323r1, nist-ir-8441, nist-ir-8270, nasa-bpg, aerospace-tor-2023-02161

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5AC-4(14)Security or Privacy Policy Filter Constraints
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5AC-4(2)Processing Domains
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5AC-4(24)Internal Normalized Format
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5AC-4(26)Audit Filtering Actions
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5AC-4(31)Failed Content Transfer Prevention
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5AC-4(32)Process Requirements for Information Transfer
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5AC-4(6)Metadata
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5AC-6Least Privilege
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data, nist-ir-8401, nist-ir-8323r1, nist-ir-8441, nist-ir-8270, aerospace-tor-2023-02161

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5AU-12Audit Record Generation
    addresses
    moderate

    AU-12 addresses audit-record generation on on-board-value modifications whose review surfaces tampering.

  • nist-80053-rev5AU-14Session Audit
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data, nist-ir-8401, nist-ir-8323r1, nist-ir-8441, aerospace-tor-2023-02161

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5AU-2Event Logging
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data, nist-ir-8401, nist-ir-8323r1, nist-ir-8441, aerospace-tor-2023-02161

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5AU-3Content of Audit Records
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data, nist-ir-8401, nist-ir-8323r1, nist-ir-8441, aerospace-tor-2023-02161

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5AU-3(1)Additional Audit Information
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5AU-4Audit Log Storage Capacity
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data, nist-ir-8401, nist-ir-8323r1, nist-ir-8441, aerospace-tor-2023-02161

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5AU-4(1)Transfer to Alternate Storage
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5AU-5Response to Audit Logging Process Failures
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data, aerospace-tor-2023-02161

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5AU-5(2)Real-time Alerts
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5AU-5(5)Alternate Audit Logging Capability
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5AU-6(1)Automated Process Integration
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5AU-6(4)Central Review and Analysis
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5AU-8Time Stamps
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data, aerospace-tor-2023-02161

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5AU-9Protection of Audit Information
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data, aerospace-tor-2023-02161

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5AU-9(2)Store on Separate Physical Systems or Components
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5AU-9(3)Cryptographic Protection
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5CA-3Information Exchange
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data, nist-ir-8401, nist-ir-8323r1, nist-ir-8441, nasa-bpg, aerospace-tor-2023-02161

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5CA-3(6)Transfer Authorizations
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5CA-3(7)Transitive Information Exchanges
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5CA-7(6)Automation Support for Monitoring
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5CM-11User-installed Software
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data, nist-ir-8401, nist-ir-8323r1, csf-2-0, nist-ir-8441, aerospace-tor-2023-02161

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5CM-11(3)Automated Enforcement and Monitoring
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5CM-3Configuration Change Control
    addresses
    moderate

    CM-3 addresses change-control governance for any modification to on-board parameters, tables, or schedules.

  • nist-80053-rev5CM-5Access Restrictions for Change
    mitigates
    high

    CM-5 mitigates EX-0012 by gating on-board-value changes behind access restrictions.

  • nist-80053-rev5CM-7Least Functionality
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data, nist-ir-8401, nist-ir-8323r1, nist-ir-8441, nist-ir-8270, aerospace-tor-2023-02161

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5CM-7(5)Authorized Software — Allow-by-exception
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5CM-7(8)Binary or Machine Executable Code
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5CP-10System Recovery and Reconstitution
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data, nist-ir-8401, nist-ir-8323r1, csf-2-0, nist-ir-8441, nist-ir-8270, aerospace-tor-2023-02161

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5CP-10(4)Restore Within Time Period
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5CP-12Safe Mode
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data, nist-ir-8401, nist-ir-8323r1, nist-ir-8441, nasa-bpg, aerospace-tor-2023-02161

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5CP-2Contingency Plan
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data, nist-ir-8401, nist-ir-8323r1, nist-ir-8441, nist-ir-8270, nasa-bpg, aerospace-tor-2023-02161

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5CP-2(5)Continue Mission and Business Functions
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5CP-4(5)Self-challenge
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5CP-9System Backup
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data, nist-ir-8401, nist-ir-8441, aerospace-tor-2023-02161

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5IR-3Incident Response Testing
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data, nist-ir-8401, nist-ir-8323r1, nist-ir-8441

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5IR-3(1)Automated Testing
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5IR-3(2)Coordination with Related Plans
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5IR-4Incident Handling
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data, nist-ir-8401, nist-ir-8323r1, nist-ir-8441, nist-ir-8270, nasa-bpg, aerospace-tor-2023-02161

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5IR-4(11)Integrated Incident Response Team
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5IR-4(12)Malicious Code and Forensic Analysis
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5IR-4(14)Security Operations Center
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5IR-4(3)Continuity of Operations
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5IR-4(5)Automatic Disabling of System
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5IR-5Incident Monitoring
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data, nist-ir-8401, nist-ir-8323r1, nist-ir-8441, nist-ir-8270, aerospace-tor-2023-02161

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5IR-5(1)Automated Tracking, Data Collection, and Analysis
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5PE-10Emergency Shutoff
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data, csf-2-0, aerospace-tor-2023-02161

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5PE-11Emergency Power
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data, nist-ir-8401, nist-ir-8323r1, csf-2-0, nist-ir-8441, nist-ir-8270

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5PE-11(1)Alternate Power Supply — Minimal Operational Capability
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5PE-14Environmental Controls
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data, nist-ir-8401, csf-2-0

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5PE-20Asset Monitoring and Tracking
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data, nist-ir-8401, nist-ir-8323r1, csf-2-0, nist-ir-8441, aerospace-tor-2023-02161

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5PL-8Security and Privacy Architectures
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data, nist-ir-8401, nist-ir-8323r1, nist-ir-8441, nist-ir-8270, aerospace-tor-2023-02161

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5PL-8(1)Defense in Depth
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5RA-10Threat Hunting
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data, nist-ir-8401, csf-2-0, nist-ir-8441, nist-ir-8270, aerospace-tor-2023-02161

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5RA-3(4)Predictive Cyber Analytics
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SA-17(7)Structure for Least Privilege
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SA-3System Development Life Cycle
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data, nist-ir-8401, nist-ir-8323r1, nist-ir-8441, aerospace-tor-2023-02161

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SA-4(5)System, Component, and Service Configurations
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SA-4(9)Functions, Ports, Protocols, and Services in Use
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SA-8Security and Privacy Engineering Principles
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data, nist-ir-8401, nist-ir-8323r1, nist-ir-8441, nasa-bpg, aerospace-tor-2023-02161

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SA-8(10)Hierarchical Trust
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SA-8(12)Hierarchical Protection
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SA-8(13)Minimized Security Elements
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SA-8(14)Least Privilege
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SA-8(15)Predicate Permission
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SA-8(18)Trusted Communications Channels
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SA-8(19)Continuous Protection
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SA-8(21)Self-analysis
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SA-8(22)Accountability and Traceability
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SA-8(23)Secure Defaults
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SA-8(24)Secure Failure and Recovery
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SA-8(26)Performance Security
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SA-8(29)Repeatable and Documented Procedures
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SA-8(3)Modularity and Layering
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SA-8(30)Procedural Rigor
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SA-8(4)Partially Ordered Dependencies
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SA-8(9)Trusted Components
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SA-9External System Services
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data, nist-ir-8401, nist-ir-8323r1, nist-ir-8441, nist-ir-8270, aerospace-tor-2023-02161

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SC-16(2)Anti-spoofing Mechanisms
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SC-16(3)Cryptographic Binding
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SC-2(2)Disassociability
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SC-24Fail in Known State
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data, nist-ir-8401, csf-2-0, aerospace-tor-2023-02161

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SC-28Protection of Information at Rest
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data, nist-ir-8401, nist-ir-8323r1, csf-2-0, nist-ir-8441, nist-ir-8270, aerospace-tor-2023-02161

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SC-28(1)Cryptographic Protection
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SC-3Security Function Isolation
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data, nist-ir-8401, nist-ir-8441, nist-ir-8270, aerospace-tor-2023-02161

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SC-3(4)Module Coupling and Cohesiveness
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SC-32System Partitioning
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data, csf-2-0, nist-ir-8270, nasa-bpg, aerospace-tor-2023-02161

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SC-32(1)Separate Physical Domains for Privileged Functions
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SC-39Process Isolation
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data, csf-2-0, aerospace-tor-2023-02161

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SC-4Information in Shared System Resources
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data, nist-ir-8401, nist-ir-8441, nist-ir-8270, aerospace-tor-2023-02161

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SC-45System Time Synchronization
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data, aerospace-tor-2023-02161

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SC-45(1)Synchronization with Authoritative Time Source
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SC-45(2)Secondary Authoritative Time Source
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SC-49Hardware-enforced Separation and Policy Enforcement
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data, csf-2-0

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SC-5Denial-of-service Protection
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data, nist-ir-8401, nist-ir-8323r1, nist-ir-8441, nist-ir-8270, nasa-bpg, aerospace-tor-2023-02161

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SC-5(3)Detection and Monitoring
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SC-50Software-enforced Separation and Policy Enforcement
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SC-6Resource Availability
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data, nist-ir-8401, nist-ir-8323r1, nist-ir-8441, nist-ir-8270, aerospace-tor-2023-02161

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SC-7(10)Prevent Exfiltration
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SC-7(20)Dynamic Isolation and Segregation
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SC-7(21)Isolation of System Components
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SC-7(29)Separate Subnets to Isolate Functions
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SC-7(5)Deny by Default — Allow by Exception
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SC-7(9)Restrict Threatening Outgoing Communications Traffic
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SC-8Transmission Confidentiality and Integrity
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data, nist-ir-8401, nist-ir-8323r1, nist-ir-8441, nist-ir-8270, nasa-bpg, aerospace-tor-2023-02161

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SC-8(2)Pre- and Post-transmission Handling
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SI-10(5)Restrict Inputs to Trusted Sources and Approved Formats
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SI-10(6)Injection Prevention
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SI-11Error Handling
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data, aerospace-tor-2023-02161

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SI-12Information Management and Retention
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data, nist-ir-8323r1, csf-2-0, aerospace-tor-2023-02161

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SI-13Predictable Failure Prevention
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data, nist-ir-8323r1, csf-2-0, aerospace-tor-2023-02161

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SI-13(4)Standby Component Installation and Notification
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SI-16Memory Protection
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data, nist-ir-8323r1, csf-2-0, aerospace-tor-2023-02161

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SI-17Fail-safe Procedures
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data, nist-ir-8323r1, nasa-bpg, aerospace-tor-2023-02161

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SI-3Malicious Code Protection
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data, nist-ir-8401, nist-ir-8323r1, nist-ir-8441, nist-ir-8270, aerospace-tor-2023-02161

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SI-3(10)Malicious Code Analysis
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SI-3(8)Detect Unauthorized Commands
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SI-4System Monitoring
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data, nist-ir-8401, nist-ir-8323r1, nist-ir-8441, nist-ir-8270, nasa-bpg, aerospace-tor-2023-02161

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SI-4(1)System-wide Intrusion Detection System
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SI-4(10)Visibility of Encrypted Communications
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SI-4(11)Analyze Communications Traffic Anomalies
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SI-4(13)Analyze Traffic and Event Patterns
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SI-4(16)Correlate Monitoring Information
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SI-4(17)Integrated Situational Awareness
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SI-4(2)Automated Tools and Mechanisms for Real-time Analysis
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SI-4(23)Host-based Devices
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SI-4(24)Indicators of Compromise
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SI-4(25)Optimize Network Traffic Analysis
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SI-4(4)Inbound and Outbound Communications Traffic
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SI-4(5)System-generated Alerts
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SI-4(7)Automated Response to Suspicious Events
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SI-6Security and Privacy Function Verification
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data, aerospace-tor-2023-02161

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SI-7Software, Firmware, and Information Integrity
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data, nist-ir-8401, nist-ir-8323r1, nist-ir-8441, nist-ir-8270, aerospace-tor-2023-02161

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SI-7(1)Integrity Checks
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SI-7(17)Runtime Application Self-protection
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SI-7(2)Automated Notifications of Integrity Violations
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SI-7(5)Automated Response to Integrity Violations
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SI-7(6)Cryptographic Protection
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • nist-80053-rev5SI-7(8)Auditing Capability for Significant Events
    relates to
    moderate

    Referenced in: sparta-data

    Mapped by SPARTA, not curated by SafeMode Space.

  • space-shieldT2054Data Manipulation
    addresses
    high

    T2054 'Data Manipulation' is the direct cross-framework counterpart of EX-0012 Modify On-Board Values — both describe inserting, deleting, or manipulating data to influence outcomes or hide activity, threatening data integrity.

SPARTA countermeasures

Cite as SafeMode Space, EX-0012 (SPARTA v3.2).

Built 2026-07-25 from 216 techniques, 334 regulation articles, 125 ENISA controls, 2,610 framework controls, and 90 countermeasures.